Wednesday, March 2, 2011

Beyond Radical- a brief book review

  "THERE IS NO SCRIPTURAL GROUND FOR ANYTHING WE PROTESTANTS PRACTICE."
This is how Gene Edwards begins his book, Beyond Radical (1999), after first stating the mission of the book: "THIS IS A CALL TO BREAK WITH THE PRESENT PRACTICE OF CHRISTIANITY IN A WAY MORE RADICAL THAN WAS KNOWN DURING THE PROTESTANT REFORMATION" (Yes, it really is printed in all caps;  I think he's trying to get someone's attention!)  He then lists more than twenty practices that we do that are not scriptural, stating that "We distort history when we try to teach that these practices are all New Testament, existed in the first century, and are 'right out of the Word of God!'"  Here's a partial list:
THE CHURCH BUILDING
PASTORS
THE ORDER OF WORSHIP
THE SERMON
THE PULPIT
THE PEW
THE CHOIR
CHAPTER AND VERSE
SUNDAY SCHOOL
THE SEMINARY
THE BIBLE SCHOOL
INTERDENOMINATIONAL AND PARA-CHURCH ORGANIZATIONS
ALL PROTESTANTS GOING TO CHURCH ON SUNDAY MORNING
THE ALTAR CALL
  Edwards' book pre-dates the similar but more comprehensive and well-known volume by Frank Viola and George Barna, Pagan Christianity.   Edwards is more famous for his other works, A Tale of Three Kings, and The Divine Romance, among others.  He and Viola have been part of the house church movement for several decades.  By the way, the modern house church movement dates back to the early 1800's, and only lately has experienced an acceleration in growth, I believe, in response to the fast-growing exodus of about one million believers in North America who are leaving the institutional church every year, and also in response to emerging changes in Western culture.  One of those major changes is the growing quest for authenticity.  The list above should explain the need for that.

3 comments:

Kaye said...

Whew! THANK YOU for explaining the all caps! *grin*

Samuel said...

I really don't like any of those things. I do however like Jesus, and Gene Edwards.

Rob Sims said...

You are a real-life example of why things need to change, Sam. According to Reggie McNeal, you are thoroughly post-modern (you come from a family of postmoderns). "Postmoderns are wildly spiritual," says McNeal, "... Just when the church adopted a business model, the culture went looking for God."